Ex-PACOM worker gets 7 years for divulging secrets to Chinese girlfriend

By AUDREY McAVOY 

The Associated Press

Published: September 17, 2014

The home of civilian defense contractor Benjamin Pierce Bishop in Kapolei, Hawaii, on March 18, 2013. Bishop was charged with giving national security secrets to a 27-year-old Chinese woman he was dating. Authorities conducting a covert search of Bishop's home in Kapolei found 12 documents marked "secret" even though he wasn't authorized to keep classified papers at home, a complaint said.

OSKAR GARCIA/AP

RELATED

• Retired Army officer to be sentenced in Hawaii military secrets case

  A former civilian defense contractor is being sentenced for divulging military secrets to his Chinese girlfriend and keeping classified documents at his suburban Honolulu home. Benjamin Bishop, a retired Army Reserve lieutenant colonel, was to be sentenced in federal court on Wednesday.
• 

  Retired officer faces 20 years for sharing military secrets with Chinese girlfriend

  Benjamin Pierce Bishop pleaded guilty to one count of communicating national defense information to a person not entitled to receive it and one count of willful retention of national defense information.

• Ex-defense worker held without bail over leaks

  A federal judge ordered former Camp Smith defense worker Benjamin Bishop to remain in custody pending trial Monday after reading a letter from the U.S. Pacific Command chief of staff and viewing some of the classified documents the FBI says it recovered from Bishop’s home.

• Pacific Command contractor charged with spying

  A civilian defense employee in Hawaii charged with leaking classified information about nuclear weapons, early-warning radar systems and other secrets to a Chinese national who was his girlfriend may have been targeted because he had access to such information, the FBI says.

HONOLULU — A former civilian defense contractor working at the U.S. military's Pacific headquarters was sentenced to seven years and three months in prison on Wednesday for divulging military secrets to his Chinese girlfriend and keeping classified documents at his Honolulu home.

Benjamin Bishop demonstrated poor judgment and jeopardized national security because of an intimate relationship, said U.S. District Court Judge Leslie Kobayashi during his sentencing hearing. That he would risk everything showed the girlfriend "has control over you," the judge told Bishop.

Bishop's move to contact the girlfriend from a halfway house he was allowed to stay at while awaiting trial, even though he was forbidden to do so, showed a continued lapse of judgment, she said.

"This makes the court question your ability to follow the law when it comes to this person," Kobayashi said.

Bishop, 60, will get credit for about a year he's already spent at the federal detention center in Honolulu since his arrest in March 2013. He faced up to 10 years in prison for each of two counts.

Defense attorney Birney Bervar argued Bishop should be sentenced to time served.

"He made an error, a serious error in judgment over the love of a woman. As one of his friends said in a letter quoting Shakespeare, 'he loved not wisely, but too well,'" Bervar told reporters.

The girlfriend was a Fulbright scholar working on her doctorate in security issues at a U.S. university.

Bishop pleaded guilty in March, saying he mentioned a classified conference between U.S. and South Korean officials while responding to an email from the girlfriend, who is in her late 20s.

He also admitted to keeping classified documents at his home, including ones outlining the U.S. Pentagon's China strategy and the U.S. military's force posture in Asia and the Pacific.

Bishop told Kobayashi his only intent was to help his friend, whom he called a "brilliant academic."

"In my efforts to help her, I went too far and made mistakes," he said.

Bishop worked in the field of cyber defense at the U.S. Pacific Command in Hawaii from May 2011 until his arrest. Before that, he helped develop Pacific Command strategy and policy. He retired from the U.S. Army Reserve as a lieutenant colonel a year ago.

Authorities have not released the girlfriend's identity or whereabouts or said publicly whether they think she was working for the Chinese government. She was a Chinese national and living in the United States as a student, according to the FBI.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Ken Sorenson told the court Bishop should have known better as an experienced Army officer, noting countries use sexual relationships to gather military secrets.

"All of the warning signs were there and he disregarded them," Sorenson said in court.

He said the girlfriend made Bishop her pawn, as she had him research classified documents to give her information.

Sorenson called the sentence fair.

"We think it sends a message that individuals who compromise U.S. national security by disclosing classified information are going to face severe sanctions," Sorenson told reporters.