Fire-damaged Vancouver mansion sparks heritage fight with unscrupulous owners

Fire-damaged Vancouver mansion sparks heritage fight

Open this photo in gallery:

3737 Angus Dr. in Vancouver.

PATRICK GUNN

PUBLISHED FEBRUARY 22, 2018UPDATED FEBRUARY 22, 2018

The heritage mansion at 3737 Angus Dr. looked like a write-off after it mysteriously went up in flames early on a Sunday morning last October.

However, the city has deemed that the house is very much salvageable, with more than 60 per cent of it intact, according to former Heritage Commission chair Richard Keate. The owner will have to restore it, not necessarily to its original state, but to an approximation of the original Tudor Revival that was built in 1910 by famous architect Samuel Maclure.

It's good news for heritage advocates, and not just because they like old houses. It sends an invaluable message that protected houses will be protected – and that a torched house is not automatically a demolished house.

From the get-go, the fire department had said the fire was "suspicious."

"Virtually 100 per cent of vacant house fires are deemed suspicious," says Captain Jonathan Gormick, public information officer for Fire and Rescue Services.

It has since been confirmed that it was indeed "maliciously set," he says.

Capt. Gormick said that contrary to initial reports, however, the arsonist did not light the fire in several spots around the house, but most likely in a single location.

He said the fire department did not have enough evidence to press charges against anyone.

The Angus Drive house had been added to the Heritage Register as an "A" category building in May, 2014. It is assessed at $14,216,000, and had been left empty for many years, except for a brief spell when it was rented out to a group of people. No one was living in the house at the time of the fire.

Capt. Gormick says empty houses are a particular risk to firefighters because of the unknowns. Firefighters must assume someone could be inside the house, either lawfully or unlawfully, so they have no choice but to check, putting themselves in danger. As well, they run the risk that the house might be missing walls or doors, which would normally help contain a fire. If the house is unoccupied and neglected, it could have unstable staircases or holes in the floors. And an empty house that catches fire poses an obvious risk to neighbours.

The restoration of 3737 Angus Dr. is not off to an easy start. The house has remained uncovered throughout the winter months. With a good deal of the roof gone, the house's previously pristine interior has been exposed to rain, sleet and snow.

Mind you, further damage doesn't mean the house won't be saved, civic historian and consultant John Atkin says. He says that leaving the house vulnerable to further deterioration is only going to cost the owner further expense in his requirement to rebuild and restore it as it was.

"It won't alter the fact that what goes on that site will look largely like what is there now," he says. "It seems silly to not protect it in some way because you are just adding to the overall cost of everything."

Heritage expert Don Luxton doesn't understand why there's been a four-month delay in covering the roof. "The movie industry could have covered that in a day," he says. "The issue was you have to stabilize it and keep the water out. That was supposed to happen. If it hasn't, then they are dragging their heels."

The city ordered the owner to install a protective covering over the house on Nov. 1. The owner had asked for two extensions and was ultimately given until Feb. 16 to comply. The reason for the extension had to do with structural hazards and WorkSafeBC requirements. As of Sunday, the house remained uncovered, its interior subject to a fresh layer of snow.

The Angus Drive house had been much loved and was a pristine example of old-world craftsmanship; a historic beauty, both inside and out, with its peaked gables and half-timbered exterior.

Miaofei Pan and wife Wenhuan Yang are listed as the homeowners of 3737 Angus Dr. A year prior to the fire, Mr. Pan was in the news after he hosted Prime Minister Justin Trudeau at a Liberal Party fundraiser at another house he owns on the west side. At the time, he told The Globe and Mail that he lobbied Prime Minister Trudeau to make the process easier for wealthy investors to come to Canada from China.

Trudeau and Pan are very close...

Mr. Pan is a real estate developer and businessman with a complicated history both in Canada and China. He has owned two other homes in Richmond. Those houses had been the subject of safety infractions in 2011 and 2015, as reported by Globe reporters Kathy Tomlinson and Xiao Xu. The houses were held by Mr. Pan's company and, despite the hazards, had more than 13 people living in them. Ms. Tomlinson and Ms. Xu also found out that Mr. Pan and his wife had been on a Chinese government "list of dishonest persons" because they had disobeyed a court order to pay out a $2.2-million loan from an asset-management firm that they had personally guaranteed. Mr. Pan had a long history of alleged debts and lawsuits in China, according to online Chinese language court records.

The couple rented out their Angus Drive mansion to a group of young people who used the house for parties and events in 2016.

Mr. Pan and Ms. Wang have made no public comment about the house, nor have they advised the city of their intentions.

The previous owner had done a painstakingly sensitive and meticulous update to the house, the interiors of which can be seen online in a realtor video. They'd proved that a heritage house could be added to without compromising its historical value, Mr. Atkin says.

"They had really done a superb job on the house and treated it with great respect, and yet added a substantial amount to the property that most people couldn't see," he says.

The house became one of the 317 pre-1940 houses covered under the First Shaughnessy Heritage Conservation Area (HCA) in September, 2015, protecting it from demolition. Vancouver got its very first HCA because the old houses had become targets of rampant redevelopment over the years. It took significant public consultation and was met with angry pushback from homeowners, who feared a drop in property values.

If the owner had wanted to bulldoze the house, he'd have to prove that it was unsalvageable.

Heritage experts worry that if Mr. Pan had been allowed to build new, it would have sent the message to other heritage-home owners that a neglected house – or a burned-out one – is an effective way to get around conservation rules.

"There is a concern about vacant houses," Mr. Luxton says. "The city doesn't want people to see this as a solution to getting rid of buildings they don't want, because it's dangerous. This is serious stuff."

As part of the Heritage Action Plan, the city also introduced a Heritage Property Standards of Maintenance by-law that requires an owner of a house in the HCA to repair and maintain the house, and to prevent water penetration. The by-law targets owners who might use "demolition by neglect" in order to justify the removal of a heritage house.

"Certainly for Shaughnessy, because a number of houses have been left abandoned for years and years, that kind of demolition by neglect thing is a strategy," says Michael Kluckner, chair of the Vancouver Heritage Commission.

"You've got to maintain the site, and the house. Currently, with the new vacant house rule, that is adding another level to it," he says, referring to the city's new Empty Homes Tax of 1 per cent of the house's value, if left vacant. "But potentially that amount of money is not significant to people," he adds.

It's the first time that the city will be put to the test when it comes to enforcing the bylaw that protects historic houses within the First Shaughnessy Heritage Conservation Area, he says.

"We will see. In a way, it's 'who will blink first?' as to whether the city will stand up for the HCA. When I look at the way the city enacts bylaws and then doesn't enforce them … it doesn't give me a huge amount of confidence. But I hope they will send the clear message that these buildings are here to stay."

In an e-mail, the city suggested it would push for the owner to rebuild and reconstruct any damaged parts of the house. In order to do any major work on the house, he'd have to apply for a Heritage Alteration Permit (HAP).

"The director of planning could refuse a Heritage Alteration Permit application to significantly alter/demolish/replace the protected heritage building because it would negatively impact the building's heritage value/character," city staff said, "but would support an HAP to rebuild/reconstruct damaged components."

Mr. Atkin says that even though Mr. Pan will have to restore the house, it won't necessarily be true to its Tudor Revival glory: The authenticity of materials and workmanship isn't a requirement. While HCAs usually follow strict federal conservation guidelines, the Vancouver version doesn't.

"There isn't a benchmark for conservation," says Mr. Atkin, who was an outspoken critic of the omission at the time the Shaughnessy HCA was established.

As a result, the houses can be turned into replicas.

"It's volumetric preservation, which is preserving the volume of structure there, but in the end you have a new structure."

He cites a large house on Hudson, off the Crescent, which has been undergoing a two-year renovation. The interior was gutted and rebuilt, the exterior replaced with a "very good exact replica."

"What you have standing there is a house that, for all intents and purposes, is brand new," he says. "So it is really about rooflines and volume, but I think it's a misnomer to call First Shaughnessy a 'conservation area,' because almost no conservation is being done there."

Pan is also a member of the Canadian- Chinese Economy and Trade Forum 

https://www.evensi.ca/2018canada-china-economy-trade-forum-2018-%E7%BE%8E%E4%B8%BD%E6%B5%99%E6%B1%9F%E5%8A%A0%E4%B8%AD%E7%BB%8F%E8%B4%B8%E8%AE%BA%E5%9D%9B-8500-warden-ave/256495802

Examples of their magazine and what they look for in Canada: Business Forum Magazine (BFM) is essential reading for Canadian and Chinese executives who want to stay up-to-date and informed of the trends, issues, activities, and perspectives that are shaping bilateral trade and investment. BFM articles cover a wide-range of topics and sectors, including cleantech, energy, agri-foods, consumer goods, manufacturing, logistics, information technology, finance, education, and trade policy. The magazine also includes interesting facts and statistics, quotes, and stories from our members, and photographs of CCBC events.

Winter Sports: Exporting Canadian Expertise (2018)

A Rally Call by Chris Freimond and Randall Mang
China’s New Financial Sector Reforms by Jennifer Reynolds
Canadian Business Partnerships with Chinese State-Owned Enterprises by Gordon Houlden
The Belt and Road Initiative: Opportunities for Canada by Howard Lin
Canada Day Birthday Fair
Canada-China Year of Tourism by David F. Goldstein
CCBC’s Canada-China Business Excellence Awards
China’s Care Economy: A Growing Export Opportunity for Canadian Women Entrepreneurs by A. Weiling Lee
How E-commerce Truly is Everywhere in China by Stewart Kiff
CCBC’s 40th Anniversary by Sarah Kutulakos, James D. Poborsa, and Deanna Horton
Setting Up Your Business in China by Jack Wu
When China Becomes Canada’s #1 by Peter Hall
Year in Review

Download magazine

Download magazine

Low-Tier Cities Offer Untapped Potential (2017)

Working Together for Bilateral Strength by LU Shaye, Ambassador of the PRC to Canada
Opportunities and Challenges for Canadian Investors by Kristina Koehler-Coluccia
From Salmon to Pandas by Melody Song, MA CFRE
China-Bound by Chia Wan Liew
Checkup Time by Randall A. Mang
CCBC’s 150th Canada Day Fair
The Canada-China Relationship by Graham Shantz, President, CCBC
Responding to Change by Ken Su
A Deeper Canada-China Economic Relationship by Walid Hejazi
CCBC’s Canada-China Business Excellence Awards
A Year in Review by Sarah Kutulakos, Executive Director, CCBC

China: Slowing Down or Revving Up? (2016)

Who is Going to Clean Up in China? by Randall A. Mang
Is China Really in a Slowdown? – What Should Your Company Do About It? by Denis L’Heureux
China’s 13th Five-Year Plan (2016-2020): Innovation, Green Development, Social Change, and Internationalization by Yves Tiberghien
China Market Research: How to Hit the Mark the First Time by Joseph Cooke
A Taste of Canada: Celebrating Canada Day in Beijing!
Reducing the Frequency and Cost of Litigation in China by Louis A. Frapporti
Courting China’s Students Good for Canada’s Businesses by Karen McBride
What You Need to Know About Employment Law in China by Gregory Sy
Investment in 5G Technology: Bridging Technology Partnerships Between Canada and China by Scott Bradley
Year in Review by Sarah Kutulakos

Download magazine

Download magazine

China Looking Out and the World Looking In (2015)

One Belt, One Road: One Unprecedented Opportunity by Randall A. Mang
The Practical Benefits (and Limitations) of the Canada-China FIPA by Matthew Kronby
Evolving Foreign Investment Review Regimes in China and Canada by Todd Liao and Sandy Walker
Canadian SMEs and China by Lorna Wright
Can You Win Online in China? by Joseph Cooke
Canada China Business Excellence Awards 2015
The Renminbi Sweetener by Daniel Koldyk
The Shifting Patterns of Chinese Investment in Canada by Gordon Houlden
Understanding Chinese Economic Reform: Where Foreign Investors Go Wrong by Chet Scheltema
Huawei’s Seeds for the Future Program Commits to Canada’s Young Aspiring Engineers by Scott Bradley and Laura Suzanne Markle
Year-End Wrap-Up by Sarah Kutulakos

Bold Plans and Ideas Begin in the Global Classroom (2014)

Canada’s Economic Diplomacy in China by Dan Ciuriak
Canada and China: The Agenda Ahead by Paul Evans
China: A Land of Opportunities and Priority by Terri-Sue Buchanan
Shanghai Free trade Zone: Triumphs, Lessons and the Way Forward by Bo Chen
Trading in Renminbi: Reducing Costs, Managing Risks by David Pavitt
Opportunities and Challenges for Canadian SMEs in China by Kristina Koehler-Coluccia
Let a Hundred Flowers Bloom by Paul Johnson
Can Canada and China Innovate Together? by Dan Herman
The Importance of the Canadian OInsolvency System to Chinese Investors by Jeffrey Carhart
China’s Urban Revolution: What’s in Store for Canadian Companies by Jessica Wilczak
Canada-China Business Innovation Begins in the Global Classroom by Karen McBride
The New China Hands: Executive Leadership in China Today by Paul von Wittgenstein
Corporate Social Responsibility: A CCBC Guide for Canadians Investing in China
A Year in Review by Sarah Kutulakos

Download magazine

Download magazine

Canada-China: Taking the Next Step (2013)

Time to Start Using the Redback? by Randall Mang
A Prescription for Healthcare Growth and Innovation by Denis L’Heureux
Don’t Miss China’s Green Wave by Stéphanie Jensen – Cormier
Alberta and China: A Coincidence of Interests by Gordon Houlden
New Minister, New Thresholds and New Rules: Canadian Foreign Investment Review Post CNOOC/Nexen by Chris Hersh and Imran Ahmad
Still Open for Business by Chris Hersh and Imran Ahmad
A Flat World of Countless Opportunities: Stories of Canadian Globalization by Hua Yu and Andrew Wright
China: a Rough and Tumble E-commerce Market Ripe with Opportunity by Randall Mang
Untapped: Canada’s Human Capital in China by Kenny Zhang
Winning China’s Talent Wars by Caleb Balloch
Food for Thought: Feeding China with Canadian Technology by Ted McKechnie
Building A Patent Highway to China by Michael J. Ladanyi and Christopher N. Hunter
Year-End Wrap-Up by Sarah Kutulakos

Understanding China: Optimize your strategy and unlock your potential (2012)

In Business to Serve (China) by Randall Mang
Investing in the Canadian Mining Sector by Cameron Mingay
The Canada-China Cleantech Connection by Denis L’Heureux
China’s Transition to a low-Carbon Society: Impacts on Business by Stephanie Jensen-Cormier
Planning Your Product Marketing Strategy in China by Chia-Yi Tung
Eight Lucky Steps to Digital Marketing in China by Joanna Wong
Weibo: China’s Social Media and You by Mark Roswell/Dashan
Selling into China by Kristina Koehler
Listing of Chinese Companies on the Toronto Stock Exchange or TSX Venture Exchange by Michael Melanson and Shaira Nanji
Wanted: An Asia Strategy by Donald Campbell, Paul Evans, and Pierre Lortie
The New Canada-China Investment Treaty: A Modest Step Toward Closer Trade and Investment Relations by Robert Wisner
Year-End Wrap-Up by Sarah Kutulakos

Download magazine

Download magazine

Your Asian Future: Charting A Path to Success in China (2011)

Canada’s Asia Future: A Strategic Proposal by Jessica Wilczak
Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises: Preparing for Success in China by the Honourable Ed Fast
Elasto Proxy: CCBC’s Business Incubation Centre’s First Resident by Doug Sharpe and Alexis Milinusic
Selling Consumer Products Into Canada: What Manufacturers, Distributors, Importers, and Retailers Need to Know by Daniel Kiselbach
Huawei Canada’s Expanding Canadian Footprint by Scott Bradley
China’s Burgeoning Sectors: Introduction by Jacques Lacasse
B.C. Lumber Success in China Market by Fred Spoke
China Spells New Opportunities for Luxury Brands by Ellen Jin
China – A Growing Opportunity for Agri-Foods in Saskatchewan by Brad Wall
China: Global Cleantech Supermarket and Partner by Nicholas Parker
Differences in Culture and Business Practices by Jianwei Zhang
The National Conversation on Asia by Douglas Goold