The Global Intelligence Files,
5543061
emails released so far
[OS] CHINA/CSM - Triads thrive in Ho's casinos, US report says
Released on 2013-08-04 00:00 GMT
| Email-ID | 321234 |
|---|---|
| Date | 2010-03-19 11:37:16 |
| From | chris.farnham@stratfor.com |
| To | os@stratfor.com |
Triads thrive in Ho's casinos, US report says
VIP rooms in Macau opened door for organised crime, regulators allege
Neil Gough [IMG] Email to friend Print a copy Bookmark and Share
Mar 19, 2010 l close r
[IMG]
http://www.scmp.com/portal/site/SCMP/menuitem.2af62ecb329d3d7733492d9253a0a0a0/?vgnextoid=1fcaa5a83f177210VgnVCM100000360a0a0aRCRD&ss=China&s=News
Macau gaming magnate Stanley Ho Hung-sun is an associate of known and suspected triads who has permitted "organised crime to operate and thrive
within his casinos", according to a report by the New Jersey state attorney general's Division of Gaming Enforcement.
The 88-year-old billionaire, who headed Macau's casino monopoly for over four decades, has counted alleged members of the 14K and Sun Yee On triad
societies among his associates, the 74-page report, made public on Wednesday, says. ( See report. )
The private VIP gambling rooms Ho introduced to his casinos beginning in the 1980s "provided organised crime the entry into the Macau gaming
market that it had previously lacked", it says.
The report was filed by the DGE in May last year, and classed as confidential. It followed a four-year investigation into the suitability of
casino operator MGM Mirage's Macau joint venture with Ho's daughter Pansy Ho Chiu-king. It was made public on Wednesday by the New Jersey Casino
Control Commission as part of a divestment settlement with MGM in which the New York-listed firm agreed to sell off its 50 per cent stake in the
2,771-room Borgata casino hotel in Atlantic City, New Jersey.
For years, law enforcement and regulatory officials in Hong Kong, Australia, Canada and the US have suspected or alleged ties between criminal
syndicates and Stanley Ho's Macau casino business. But the New Jersey regulators' report contains the most high-profile allegations to have
emerged publicly.
Stanley Ho has repeatedly denied links to organised crime and has never been arrested or convicted. He remains under medical supervision after
being discharged from hospital this month following a seven-month stay after an operation to remove a blood clot in his brain.
"Dr Ho has not seen the report and does not want to speculate on what it contains," a spokeswoman said yesterday. "This is an issue for the
regulatory authorities and MGM. But his position on the record is clear that there is absolutely no foundation in any suggestion that he is
associated with organised crime or triads."
New Jersey's finding of "unsuitability" against Stanley Ho, Pansy Ho and MGM's Macau venture has not been shared by other US regulators. Gaming
industry officials in the states of Nevada and Mississippi previously ruled that the partnership between Pansy Ho and MGM was suitable but did not
consider Stanley Ho to have influence over their joint venture.
Wednesday's announcement marked MGM's exit from New Jersey, a market battered by competition from casinos in nearby Pennsylvania. The firm's
half-share of the Borgata will be placed into a trust and sold within 30 months.
MGM retains its presence in Macau, the world's largest casino market, where the firm and Pansy Ho opened the US$1.25 billion MGM Grand Macau in
December 2007.
MGM chairman and chief executive Jim Murren said last month the partners aimed for a Hong Kong listing by the third quarter.
"The DGE's report acknowledges there is no evidence that Pansy Ho has engaged in any wrongdoing or been accused of any illegal activity," Murren
said after it was released.
"MGM Mirage structured its business relationship with Pansy Ho to ensure the highest standards of operation and compliance with all applicable
gaming laws and to protect against any improper influence. We have had a very positive working relationship with Pansy Ho and have a spotless
operating record at MGM Grand Macau," he said.
The DGE report sheds new light on MGM's efforts to gain access to the Macau market. The investigation entailed 35 sworn interviews with 17 people
including Pansy Ho and her sister Daisy Ho Chiu-fung, the analysis of thousands of pages of documents, including e-mails and correspondence, and
trips to Hong Kong, Macau and other jurisdictions.
Throughout 2001, with its eye on one of the three casino licences to be awarded upon the opening up of the Macau market, MGM held talks with New
World Development chairman Cheng Yu-tung about a joint bid.
The report says Cheng and Chan Siu-hung already operated three VIP rooms at Stanley Ho's casinos, and MGM explored a partnership in which the US
firm and New World would each take a 40 per cent stake and Chan the remainder. However, these negotiations did not lead to a deal. When the three
winning bids were announced in February 2002, MGM had come in fifth.
"We licked our wounds for a bit and then tried to analyse whether there were any other opportunities for us to enter the Macau market," former MGM
executive vice-president and general counsel Gary Jacobs told the DGE investigators.
Weeks later, MGM's senior vice-president for Far East marketing, Philip Wang, visited Stanley Ho to explore possibilities with Ho's Sociedade de
Jogos de Macau (SJM), which had one of the three new licences.
"Are you serious?" Ho replied, according to the report. "We are very, very serious," Wang said.
In April 2002, Stanley Ho travelled to Las Vegas at the invitation of MGM along with business associates and family members including Pansy Ho and
Daisy Ho. Stanley Ho had dinner with Wang, MGM's then chairman and chief executive Terrence Lanni and billionaire Kirk Kerkorian, the firm's
controlling shareholder, the report says. Stanley Ho agreed to continue negotiations and appointed Pansy Ho as his representative to broker a deal
with MGM. The aim was to create a 51-49 joint venture to be led by Shun Tak Holdings (SEHK: 0242,announcements, news) , where Pansy Ho was
managing director.
As the talks stretched on, MGM was conducting its own due diligence on Shun Tak and the Ho family. Private investigators hired by MGM advised in a
March 2003 e-mail to the firm that Stanley Ho was "linked closely" to two major triads operating in Macau, the 14K and Sun Yee On, the DGE report
says.
MGM vice-president of corporate security Kyle Edwards drafted a summary of the due diligence findings that stated: "There is no doubt that by
virtue of the set-ups of the VIP rooms, Stanley has interacted with individuals that are members of triads."
By July 2003, Pansy Ho and Lanni had exchanged formal letters acknowledging the structure and basic terms of the proposed joint venture.
But the following month, MGM executives including Lanni and Jacobs were called to a meeting with Nevada Gaming Control Board member Bobby Siller,
who informally advised them regulatory approval from Nevada would be a "very difficult path" and said he would not approve any Macau partnership
that involved Stanley Ho or his firms Shun Tak, SJM or Sociedade de Turismo e Diversoes de Macau (STDM).
New Jersey was never MGM's main market, but the firm was Nevada's biggest taxpayer and the largest private employer in Las Vegas.
Stanley Ho "was upset by the news", Jacobs told New Jersey investigators. But in November that year, MGM was negotiating a new and separate
partnership with Pansy Ho directly, in her individual capacity.
"I wouldn't want to [be involved in a joint venture with Stanley Ho]. No regulator would allow us to do that," Lanni told the investigators.
"I realise he's never been indicted, he's never been convicted, but perception is reality, and maybe there is reality there also, beyond the
failure to have the indictments or convictions."
The new joint venture between MGM and Pansy Ho was formally agreed in June 2004 and called for an initial cash contribution of US$360 million. MGM
executives were worried that US regulators would take umbrage if Pansy Ho received her share of the funds from her father.
MGM increased its contribution to the venture by US$100 million "as a 'premium' to Pansy Ho for the ability and opportunity to be in business with
her in Macau", and thereby reduced her share of the burden by US$50 million, the report says.
So Pansy Ho's initial contribution was US$80 million, and the report concludes that US$72 million, or 90 per cent of that, was tied back to her
father. The partners purchased a "subconcession" casino licence from SJM in April 2005 for US$200 million.
They broke ground on their first Macau casino, the MGM Grand Macau, in June 2005. Photographs from the event tended to focus not on the building,
MGM executives or even Pansy Ho, but on her father. She told New Jersey investigators her father was an invited guest; Lanni and Jacobs said he
was not invited but showed up after the ceremony.
The DGE report concludes: "MGM's compliance failings ... were pervasive and persistent, suggesting that the company's fervour to [enter] Macau
compromised its commitment to regulatory compliance."
The Nevada regulators unanimously approved MGM's partnership with Pansy Ho in March 2007. (Siller had retired in December 2006).
Pansy Ho declined to comment yesterday. In an interview with this newspaper two years ago, she was asked if the multiple overseas suitability
probes she and her brother Lawrence Ho Yau-lung had gone through were a source of frustration or embarrassment for her father.
"I couldn't answer on behalf of him, but I would suspect yes," she said. "He had never meant to take any direct participation in anything that
respectively my brother and myself are doing now vis-a-vis our gaming ventures. So it is actually in a way unfair that he has to be brought into
the picture in all of this."
--
Chris Farnham
Watch Officer/Beijing Correspondent , STRATFOR
China Mobile: (86) 1581 1579142
Email: chris.farnham@stratfor.com
www.stratfor.com
VIP rooms in Macau opened door for organised crime, regulators allege
Neil Gough [IMG] Email to friend Print a copy Bookmark and Share
Mar 19, 2010 l close r
[IMG]
http://www.scmp.com/portal/site/SCMP/menuitem.2af62ecb329d3d7733492d9253a0a0a0/?vgnextoid=1fcaa5a83f177210VgnVCM100000360a0a0aRCRD&ss=China&s=News
Macau gaming magnate Stanley Ho Hung-sun is an associate of known and suspected triads who has permitted "organised crime to operate and thrive
within his casinos", according to a report by the New Jersey state attorney general's Division of Gaming Enforcement.
The 88-year-old billionaire, who headed Macau's casino monopoly for over four decades, has counted alleged members of the 14K and Sun Yee On triad
societies among his associates, the 74-page report, made public on Wednesday, says. ( See report. )
The private VIP gambling rooms Ho introduced to his casinos beginning in the 1980s "provided organised crime the entry into the Macau gaming
market that it had previously lacked", it says.
The report was filed by the DGE in May last year, and classed as confidential. It followed a four-year investigation into the suitability of
casino operator MGM Mirage's Macau joint venture with Ho's daughter Pansy Ho Chiu-king. It was made public on Wednesday by the New Jersey Casino
Control Commission as part of a divestment settlement with MGM in which the New York-listed firm agreed to sell off its 50 per cent stake in the
2,771-room Borgata casino hotel in Atlantic City, New Jersey.
For years, law enforcement and regulatory officials in Hong Kong, Australia, Canada and the US have suspected or alleged ties between criminal
syndicates and Stanley Ho's Macau casino business. But the New Jersey regulators' report contains the most high-profile allegations to have
emerged publicly.
Stanley Ho has repeatedly denied links to organised crime and has never been arrested or convicted. He remains under medical supervision after
being discharged from hospital this month following a seven-month stay after an operation to remove a blood clot in his brain.
"Dr Ho has not seen the report and does not want to speculate on what it contains," a spokeswoman said yesterday. "This is an issue for the
regulatory authorities and MGM. But his position on the record is clear that there is absolutely no foundation in any suggestion that he is
associated with organised crime or triads."
New Jersey's finding of "unsuitability" against Stanley Ho, Pansy Ho and MGM's Macau venture has not been shared by other US regulators. Gaming
industry officials in the states of Nevada and Mississippi previously ruled that the partnership between Pansy Ho and MGM was suitable but did not
consider Stanley Ho to have influence over their joint venture.
Wednesday's announcement marked MGM's exit from New Jersey, a market battered by competition from casinos in nearby Pennsylvania. The firm's
half-share of the Borgata will be placed into a trust and sold within 30 months.
MGM retains its presence in Macau, the world's largest casino market, where the firm and Pansy Ho opened the US$1.25 billion MGM Grand Macau in
December 2007.
MGM chairman and chief executive Jim Murren said last month the partners aimed for a Hong Kong listing by the third quarter.
"The DGE's report acknowledges there is no evidence that Pansy Ho has engaged in any wrongdoing or been accused of any illegal activity," Murren
said after it was released.
"MGM Mirage structured its business relationship with Pansy Ho to ensure the highest standards of operation and compliance with all applicable
gaming laws and to protect against any improper influence. We have had a very positive working relationship with Pansy Ho and have a spotless
operating record at MGM Grand Macau," he said.
The DGE report sheds new light on MGM's efforts to gain access to the Macau market. The investigation entailed 35 sworn interviews with 17 people
including Pansy Ho and her sister Daisy Ho Chiu-fung, the analysis of thousands of pages of documents, including e-mails and correspondence, and
trips to Hong Kong, Macau and other jurisdictions.
Throughout 2001, with its eye on one of the three casino licences to be awarded upon the opening up of the Macau market, MGM held talks with New
World Development chairman Cheng Yu-tung about a joint bid.
The report says Cheng and Chan Siu-hung already operated three VIP rooms at Stanley Ho's casinos, and MGM explored a partnership in which the US
firm and New World would each take a 40 per cent stake and Chan the remainder. However, these negotiations did not lead to a deal. When the three
winning bids were announced in February 2002, MGM had come in fifth.
"We licked our wounds for a bit and then tried to analyse whether there were any other opportunities for us to enter the Macau market," former MGM
executive vice-president and general counsel Gary Jacobs told the DGE investigators.
Weeks later, MGM's senior vice-president for Far East marketing, Philip Wang, visited Stanley Ho to explore possibilities with Ho's Sociedade de
Jogos de Macau (SJM), which had one of the three new licences.
"Are you serious?" Ho replied, according to the report. "We are very, very serious," Wang said.
In April 2002, Stanley Ho travelled to Las Vegas at the invitation of MGM along with business associates and family members including Pansy Ho and
Daisy Ho. Stanley Ho had dinner with Wang, MGM's then chairman and chief executive Terrence Lanni and billionaire Kirk Kerkorian, the firm's
controlling shareholder, the report says. Stanley Ho agreed to continue negotiations and appointed Pansy Ho as his representative to broker a deal
with MGM. The aim was to create a 51-49 joint venture to be led by Shun Tak Holdings (SEHK: 0242,announcements, news) , where Pansy Ho was
managing director.
As the talks stretched on, MGM was conducting its own due diligence on Shun Tak and the Ho family. Private investigators hired by MGM advised in a
March 2003 e-mail to the firm that Stanley Ho was "linked closely" to two major triads operating in Macau, the 14K and Sun Yee On, the DGE report
says.
MGM vice-president of corporate security Kyle Edwards drafted a summary of the due diligence findings that stated: "There is no doubt that by
virtue of the set-ups of the VIP rooms, Stanley has interacted with individuals that are members of triads."
By July 2003, Pansy Ho and Lanni had exchanged formal letters acknowledging the structure and basic terms of the proposed joint venture.
But the following month, MGM executives including Lanni and Jacobs were called to a meeting with Nevada Gaming Control Board member Bobby Siller,
who informally advised them regulatory approval from Nevada would be a "very difficult path" and said he would not approve any Macau partnership
that involved Stanley Ho or his firms Shun Tak, SJM or Sociedade de Turismo e Diversoes de Macau (STDM).
New Jersey was never MGM's main market, but the firm was Nevada's biggest taxpayer and the largest private employer in Las Vegas.
Stanley Ho "was upset by the news", Jacobs told New Jersey investigators. But in November that year, MGM was negotiating a new and separate
partnership with Pansy Ho directly, in her individual capacity.
"I wouldn't want to [be involved in a joint venture with Stanley Ho]. No regulator would allow us to do that," Lanni told the investigators.
"I realise he's never been indicted, he's never been convicted, but perception is reality, and maybe there is reality there also, beyond the
failure to have the indictments or convictions."
The new joint venture between MGM and Pansy Ho was formally agreed in June 2004 and called for an initial cash contribution of US$360 million. MGM
executives were worried that US regulators would take umbrage if Pansy Ho received her share of the funds from her father.
MGM increased its contribution to the venture by US$100 million "as a 'premium' to Pansy Ho for the ability and opportunity to be in business with
her in Macau", and thereby reduced her share of the burden by US$50 million, the report says.
So Pansy Ho's initial contribution was US$80 million, and the report concludes that US$72 million, or 90 per cent of that, was tied back to her
father. The partners purchased a "subconcession" casino licence from SJM in April 2005 for US$200 million.
They broke ground on their first Macau casino, the MGM Grand Macau, in June 2005. Photographs from the event tended to focus not on the building,
MGM executives or even Pansy Ho, but on her father. She told New Jersey investigators her father was an invited guest; Lanni and Jacobs said he
was not invited but showed up after the ceremony.
The DGE report concludes: "MGM's compliance failings ... were pervasive and persistent, suggesting that the company's fervour to [enter] Macau
compromised its commitment to regulatory compliance."
The Nevada regulators unanimously approved MGM's partnership with Pansy Ho in March 2007. (Siller had retired in December 2006).
Pansy Ho declined to comment yesterday. In an interview with this newspaper two years ago, she was asked if the multiple overseas suitability
probes she and her brother Lawrence Ho Yau-lung had gone through were a source of frustration or embarrassment for her father.
"I couldn't answer on behalf of him, but I would suspect yes," she said. "He had never meant to take any direct participation in anything that
respectively my brother and myself are doing now vis-a-vis our gaming ventures. So it is actually in a way unfair that he has to be brought into
the picture in all of this."
--
Chris Farnham
Watch Officer/Beijing Correspondent , STRATFOR
China Mobile: (86) 1581 1579142
Email: chris.farnham@stratfor.com
www.stratfor.com
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments always welcome!